Also in our stash are two bumGenius Freetime all-in-ones and one bumGenius Elemental all-in-one. I got those just to try out and keep part of our "at-home" stash. The main difference in these two all-in-one styles are the fabric. The Freetime has microfiber inserts with a polyester lining and the Elemental is made of organic cotton. I think the Freetime was designed so there would be a faster line drying time because it takes forever it seems for the cotton Elemental to dry!
Recently bumGenius came out with a new version of the Elemental that eliminated the cotton lining on the bottom of the diaper. Instead, it was more like a Flip cover with the cotton insert (same as oldstyle Elemental) but nothing underneath except PUL unlike the oldstyle with cotton underneath.
I decided to take some comparison pictures of the new and old styles of the Elemental with my pocket. I forgot to include the Freetime but that's irrelevant to my post. I wanted to compare the different styles of Elemental and how it compares to our everyday use of the pockets.
Main differences between new and old Elementals:
1. New style is trimmer all around on the bum (even trimmer than the 4.0)
2. New style is wider in the crotch area, more like a 4.0
3. New style fits on RaeRae very similar to how the 4.0 fits on her (the old style must be opened to the largest setting while the new style goes on the medium setting like in the 4.0s and Freetimes)
4. Old style Elemental has a cotton layer underneath the sewn insert while the new style does not (all PUL)
5. Cost of new Elemental is the same as the old one (which I do not understand because it has less cotton fabric it seems overall? I honestly think it should be at least 2 dollar less, but that's my opinion).
See pictures below:
Old style elemental on top of new elemental |
4.0 pocket on top of new elemental |
Left to right: new Elemental, 4.0 pocket, older Elemental |
![]() |
4.0 next to new Elemental |
New Elemental next to old style Elemental |
Left to right: 4.0, newer Elemental, old style Elemental |